Free tool
Advantage or Medigap? Six questions.
Almost every Medicare decision comes down to this one fork. These questions are the ones that actually decide it for most people.
Six quick questions
0 of 6Why these six questions
Most Medicare comparisons start with cost, which is why so many people end up in the wrong place. Your doctors, your travel patterns, and how often you expect to need care all matter more, because those determine whether a network is a minor detail or a daily constraint.
The budget question is included, but it is deliberately framed around how you prefer to carry risk rather than which is cheaper. Paying more monthly to pay almost nothing at the point of care is a legitimate preference, and so is the reverse.
The asymmetry worth knowing before you choose
Switching from Medigap to Advantage is generally easy. Switching back often is not — outside your one-time Medigap open enrollment window, most states let insurers review your health and decline you. That asymmetry should carry more weight in this decision than a small difference in monthly premium.
Common questions
Should I get Medicare Advantage or Medigap?
It depends on how much you value provider freedom and predictable costs versus a lower monthly premium. Medigap has no network and covers most of what Original Medicare leaves, at a higher premium. Medicare Advantage costs less monthly, uses a network, and often adds extras. Neither is better in the abstract.
Can I switch later if I choose wrong?
Moving from Medigap to Medicare Advantage is generally straightforward. Moving the other way may not be — outside your one-time Medigap open enrollment window or a specific guaranteed-issue right, most states allow insurers to review your health and decline you.
Which one is cheaper?
Medicare Advantage usually costs less each month; Medigap usually costs less when you actually use care. Which is cheaper across a full year depends on how much care you need, so comparing total expected cost matters more than comparing premiums.
Does this quiz recommend a specific plan?
No. It points toward a path — Original Medicare with a supplement, or Medicare Advantage. Choosing an actual plan requires checking your specific doctors, prescriptions, and the options available in your county.